Planning for the Leaders Who Are Not Yet Here

Key Takeaways

  • Succession planning in most organizations, for-profit and nonprofit alike, is a board responsibility handled as an occasional event, and the research shows it is handled badly.

  • A plan that lives only at the board can name a successor, but it can’t prepare for one. Readiness is produced by the culture, many years earlier and several layers down.

  • Long-horizon traditions, including the Haudenosaunee seventh-generation principle, offer a discipline modern organizations lack: deciding today with the leaders of the distant future in the room.

  • An organization that does not plan for its own continuity is sacrificing its long-term well-being in favor of short-term priorities.

On most board calendars, there is an agenda item on succession planning maybe once a year. It gets a slide, a short discussion, and a note to revisit. This is how most organizations, for-profit and nonprofit alike, address the question of who will lead them next: as a board responsibility, addressed occasionally, and ultimately handled poorly.

A leadership team I am working with is about to run its own version of this exercise, and preparing for it has sharpened a conviction I have held for a long time. A plan that lives only at the board can certainly name a successor, but it can’t actually adequately prepare for one. Readiness is only possible through careful planning that starts many years earlier and several layers below the roles the board discusses. Here is what that means in practice.

How succession is usually done

Research from Stanford Graduate School of Business found that boards spend about two hours annually on CEO succession, and that more than half of companies could not name a successor if they had to today. The study isn’t new, but it has become the reference point because so little has changed since.

Heidrick’s latest global survey of CEOs and directors, Route to the Top, confirms this. Only 26% treat succession as a top priority and 40% say it is not a priority at all. Just 25% plan continuously, while 21% engage with the question only in emergencies.

The nonprofit sector mirrors the pattern. Only 29% of nonprofits have a written succession plan, according to the National Council of Nonprofits, while roughly half of executive directors expect to leave within five years.

Where succession is planned, the tool of choice is the 9-box grid: a three-by-three matrix that rates people on current performance along one axis and estimated future potential along the other. A majority of large organizations use some version of it in their talent reviews, and most senior leaders have sat in the meeting where names are moved between boxes. The team I mentioned is about to run exactly this exercise. The question that matters most is how the data from the grid becomes reality in the months that follow.

Why the board-only model is inadequate

The board selects, but it does not build a pipeline. Boards that plan continuously are far more confident in their bench than reactive boards, to the tune of 78% versus 20%. The reason is simple: a continuous process develops candidates over years, while an occasional one chooses among the people who happen to be at the right level at the right time. A precarious but preventable situation.

Let’s talk about why this doesn’t work:

It starts too high. The Deloitte 2026 Gen Z and Millennial Survey finds that only 54% of Gen Zs and 60% of millennials believe their team could maintain performance if a key expert left tomorrow. The reasons they give are an absence of incentive and time to share knowledge. The continuity problem is already present at the team level, where the C-suite succession plan never usually reaches.

It puts trust in a faulty exercise. A study of 30,000 management-track employees, reported by MIT Sloan, found that women received “potential” ratings 8.3% lower than men despite receiving higher performance ratings, and that the gap explained up to half of the promotion gap. Potential is a forecast, and a forecast carries the biases of the forecaster. A grid that is treated as a measurement reproduces those biases.

It treats succession as a butt-in-seat problem rather than a trust problem. An emergency exit signals to everyone below the top that the organization did not know who it was preparing to take the helm. The meticulously planned CEO transition at Apple earlier this year read as the opposite because the successor had been visibly developed in public for years; people inside and outside the company could see the plan being enacted in real time before it was announced.

The result, in most organizations, is a plan that exists on paper at the top and nowhere in the lived experience of the people who are expected to be part of the succession.

The long view

Some traditions have thought about continuity for far longer than modern organizations have. The Haudenosaunee Confederacy, the alliance of Six Nations in northeastern North America, holds a principle of weighing every decision by its effect on people seven generations ahead, including those not yet born. Yale’s Life Worth Living program describes it as a responsibility to future generations built into governance itself.

The psychology behind that discipline is now being studied. A 2025 paper in Scientific Reports found that people believe decision-makers should consider future generations further out than they actually do, and that the gap narrows when the future is made concrete as it approaches.

Translated into organizational time, seven leadership generations is roughly a working lifetime. The question I would put to any leadership team is whether the leaders of 2050 would recognize this year’s decisions as made with them in mind.

There is a practical way to put this into motion. Give one seat in the succession conversation to an early-career professional, and ask what the organization they will inherit needs from the people being developed now. Making the future concrete in the present will likely change how and what decisions are made. 

This is also a wellness argument. The organization that cannot think past the quarter does so at the expense of its people’s health, through overload, emergency exits, and perpetual restructuring. Longevity is a necessary condition of healthy work.

Building succession into the culture

Treat the 9-box as a development conversation. Each placement should leave the room with a named assignment, a named mentor, and a date.

Run it at every level, including the first rung of the ladder. The pipeline that produces a CEO starts with how first-time managers are chosen and supported, which is where my companion piece this month, What Gen Z Wants From the People Who Lead Them, begins.

Name multiple candidates per critical role, and tell them that they’re in consideration. Then, make sure that documenting and sharing knowledge with those in the succession plan is part of leader expectations. 

Put succession on every leadership agenda regularly, rather than on one board agenda sporadically. Continuity becomes a habit the way trust does: in small, regular deposits.

FAQs

Is the 9-box grid still worth using?

Yes, as a structured conversation with calibration across managers. It fails when placements become permanent labels or when the potential axis is treated as a measurement rather than a forecast.

Should the board still own succession?

The board should own accountability for it. The organization has to own the work of preparing leaders and maintaining a strong pipeline of candidates, because readiness is produced years before the board meets and several levels below the roles it discusses.

What does succession have to do with employee wellness?

Everything downstream. Emergency exits, knowledge hoarding and leaders who cannot step away are symptoms of an organization planning only for the present at the expense of future sustainability.

Closing Reflection

The leaders who will run this organization in twenty years are, in most cases, already in it, and some have not yet arrived. The work of succession is deciding, today, to be worth inheriting.

Explore More

Download the Leadership Pattern Reflection Workbook

What would the organization you lead look like to the people who inherit it? The free Leadership Pattern Reflection Workbook is made to help you see the patterns you are passing on. 

Next
Next

What Gen Z Wants From the People Who Lead Them